Can we talk about how one person's 'classic' is another person's 'dated'?
At my book club last Thursday, we were talking about 'The Great Gatsby' and a new member, Sarah, said she found the whole thing 'emotionally empty and kind of a drag.' That comment split the room right down the middle. Half of us were ready to defend it as a perfect book, and the other half agreed with her. It made me realize we all bring our own life stuff to what we read. Has your group ever had a book that caused a split like that?