Am I the only one who watched their oil go from black sludge to honey in 3 drain cycles?
Watched my oil go from straight black sludge at 190k miles to looking like honey after just 3 changes with cheap $18 Walmart high mileage oil every 3k miles, so now I'm wondering if anyone else has seen a beater engine clean itself up this fast or if I'm just fooling myself.
Black sludge turning honey in 3k miles sounds more like fresh oil sitting on top of old crud than an engine actually cleaning itself. That color you're seeing on the dipstick is just the new stuff doing its job, not proof the inside is spotless. Cheap high mileage oil every 3k for 190k miles isn't hurting anything, but don't count on it fixing what's already caked on the rings and lifters.