I finally cured that phantom knock after 4 days, but was it worth it?
So I chased a knocking noise on a 2012 F-150 for basically 4 straight days. Thought it was the lifters, pulled the valve covers, checked everything, nothing. Then I looked at the flexplate bolts, they were fine. Turned out it was a loose torque converter bolt that was maybe 1/8 inch backed out, and it only showed up when the trans warmed up to operating temp. Took me 30 minutes to fix once I found it. Here's my debate: is the slow systematic approach better because you learn the whole system, or should you just start with the most likely cheap fix first? I had a buddy who would've thrown a new torque converter at it day one and it would've solved it, but that's $700 in parts versus my $0 fix after burning a week. Has anyone else had a job where the long way actually taught you more than the shortcut, or do you always kick yourself for not trying the obvious thing? What's your call?
But your buddy throwing a $700 part at it is gambling, not fixing, and he'd still be guessing if that wasn't it. Four days of learning how the whole system talks to each other beats one lucky guess every time.