Update: a stuck tube sheet on a small boiler cost me 11 hours, so is heat or patience the right call?
Spent 11 hours over two days last week trying to work a rolled tube out of a sheet on a little 100 hp unit in Gary, and I want to hear how you all handle it. I went the slow route with a torch and it kept grabbing, so I switched to cutting and drilling and it still fought me the whole way. One guy I know swears you warm the sheet evenly and let the tube walk out on its own, but another old hand told me heat just makes it worse and you should go cold with a good bit and steady pressure. I ended up getting it with a die grinder and a lot of cussing, way past when I told the customer I'd be done. So which side are you on, heat or patience, and what actually gets a stuck tube out fastest for you?