Three years of a phantom creak turned out to be my saddle rail, not the bottom bracket
Back in 2021 I chased a tick on my commuter for about 3 years, swapping the bottom bracket twice and even buying a new crank bolt set at the shop on Grand Ave. Finally a coworker at the bench next to me grabbed the saddle and twisted it, and the noise matched exactly, one loose rail clamp. I felt pretty silly after all that parts money. How do you all narrow down creaks before you start pulling the crank?