Loading…
10
Chat with an old timer at the shop made me rethink my feeds and speeds
Was running a tough stainless job yesterday, fighting chatter. Guy who ran this machine for 20 years walks over, watches for a minute. He just said, 'You're scared of the machine. Let it eat.' Dropped my feed rate by 15% and bumped the spindle up 200 rpm. Cut like butter, finish was perfect. How do you guys approach a noisy cut on a new material?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
logan_dixon186mo ago
Man, that's it right there. I was fighting some nasty aluminum chatter for a week, kept backing off. My foreman finally told me to stop babying it and push the feed. Went up on the feed rate and it just cleaned up, chip load was perfect. Sometimes you gotta trust the tool to do its job instead of trying to save it. That old guy knowledge is gold.
7
drew8056mo ago
Exactly, that "stop babying it" advice is key. It's a weird balance where backing off makes things worse because you're rubbing instead of cutting. The tool needs enough bite to pull the vibration out of the cut. I've learned to listen to the sound more than anything. A high pitched squeal usually means you need to push harder, not lighter. What's the first thing you try when a cut starts singing?
6
leo_lopez3mo ago
That reminds me, my buddy @logan_dixon18 had the exact same problem with some 6061 a while back. He was about to chuck the end mill in the scrap bin when I told him to just jam it in there harder. He looked at me like I was crazy but tried it and it cut like butter. Now he just yells "MORE COWBELL" every time a cut starts screaming.
2