Started logging my solo plays in a little notebook and it actually fixed my game picking problem
So six months ago I had this huge shelf of games and would just stare at it every Friday night and end up playing nothing. I counted once and I have 41 games but I kept replaying the same two over and over. I started writing down each solo game I played in a cheap spiral notebook, just the name, date, and a one line note like "won on hard, felt tense" or "boring by round 4." After about 30 entries I flipped back through it and it was kind of eye opening, I had played Spirit Island nine times and some games I bought in 2023 I never touched. Now I keep the notebook on top of the shelf and before I pick a game I glance at the last page to see what I actually felt like playing recently. It sounds dumb but seeing it in my own handwriting hits different than a spreadsheet. Has anyone else tried keeping a physical play log, or do you all just use BGG stats?
The one line note part is what would make this work for me, not just the name and date. A plain "played Tuesday" tells you nothing six weeks later, but "boring by round 4" is a little time capsule of your mood. You could go one step further and jot a quick gut rating like a 1 to 5 next to it, then flip through and look for patterns, like which games only get played when you're tired versus when you have real energy. I bet the nine Spirit Island plays all have a similar note on them, and that tells you what you're actually chasing on a Friday night.